Compliance
Breaks, Rest and the Rota: What the Law Actually Requires
Most rota breaches are not decisions. They are an eleven hour gap that turned out to be ten, noticed by nobody until it had been worked.
Almost nobody sets out to breach the Working Time Regulations. What happens is more ordinary: someone closes on Friday, opens on Saturday, and the gap between the two turns out to be nine and a half hours. Nobody counted, because counting is tedious and the rota was already late.
Here is the short version of what the rules require, in the order you are most likely to trip over them. It is a checklist to run a week against, not legal advice, and the Acas guidance on rest is worth reading in full if you want the detail.
The twenty minute break
A worker whose daily working time is more than six hours is entitled to an uninterrupted rest break of at least twenty minutes. Three details catch people out. It must be during the shift, not bolted onto the start or the end, so sending someone home twenty minutes early does not discharge it. It must be uninterrupted, which a break spent answering the phone is not. And it is a minimum, not a maximum, and unpaid unless the contract says otherwise.
The eleven hour gap
This is the one rotas break most often. Workers are entitled to eleven consecutive hours of rest in each twenty four hour period. Close the bar at half eleven, cash up until midnight, and the earliest that person can lawfully start the next day is eleven in the morning. An eight o'clock open is not a tight turnaround, it is a breach.
The close-then-open pairing is so common in hospitality and retail that it has a nickname, and it is worth searching your week specifically for it before publishing. It is also, as it happens, one of the fastest ways to make a good employee start reading job adverts.
The forty eight hour week
Average working time is limited to forty eight hours a week, calculated over a reference period that is normally seventeen weeks. Two things follow. It is an average, so one heavy week is not automatically a problem. And an adult worker can opt out of the limit in writing, voluntarily, with the right to opt back in on notice. An opt-out cannot be a condition of getting shifts, and it does not touch the rest break or daily rest entitlements above, which stand regardless.
Weekly rest
On top of daily rest, workers are entitled to either twenty four uninterrupted hours off each week, or forty eight hours off each fortnight. In practice, if you are giving two consecutive days off most weeks you are comfortably clear; if you are running six short shifts across seven days, check it deliberately.
Under 18s: a stricter set of rules entirely
This is the section worth reading twice, because a lot of pubs, cafes and shops employ sixth formers and apply the adult rules to them by accident. Young workers get a thirty minute break when daily working time exceeds four and a half hours, not twenty minutes after six. They get twelve consecutive hours of daily rest, not eleven. And they get forty eight hours of weekly rest which, unlike the adult entitlement, cannot be averaged across a fortnight.
If you employ under 18s, the honest approach is to plan their shifts against the stricter numbers rather than trying to remember which rule applies to whom at nine o'clock on a Sunday night.
Put the rules where the rota is
Every one of these is easy to comply with and easy to miss, and the difference between the two is almost always visibility. A rota spread across a whole week on one screen makes a late finish above an early start obvious. A rota built column by column in a spreadsheet, or in your head at the end of a fourteen hour day, does not. If you are still doing it the second way, our five minute method is a gentler place to start than you might expect.